Non-freezing cold injury Non-freezing cold injury

Non-freezing cold injury

This was one case brought to trial in the multi-claimant non-freezing cold injury (NFCI) litigation. The case illustrates the challenges for...
One tray short of a baker’s dozen: injury on the production line One tray short of a baker’s dozen: injury on the production line

One tray short of a baker’s dozen: injury on the production line

This case concerns an important boundary matter that sometimes arises for orthopaedic experts in relation to biomechanics and ergonomics. These are...
Expert appoints herself as social worker, psychologist, therapist and judge Expert appoints herself as social worker, psychologist, therapist and judge

Expert appoints herself as social worker, psychologist, therapist and judge

At a time when psychologists in particular are concerned about psychological evidence being given by psychologists who are unregulated, this case...
Procedure for Determining Mental Capacity in Civil Proceedings Procedure for Determining Mental Capacity in Civil Proceedings

Procedure for Determining Mental Capacity in Civil Proceedings

A Civil Justice Council working group has published a report setting out recommendations for the development of a procedure for determing mental...
Podcast Episode 6: In Conversation with Giles Eyre Podcast Episode 6: In Conversation with Giles Eyre

Podcast Episode 6: In Conversation with Giles Eyre

In the 6th Episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, Simon talks with retired Barrister and expert witness trainer, Giles Eyre, who is retiring as an EWI...
A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness

Sue Lightman is a Professor of Ophthalmology and Consultant Ophthalmologist who has been undertaking medicolegal Expert Witness work for over 20...
Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner

Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner

We are pleased to welcome a new Corporate Partner
Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture

Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture

Successful Certification candidates receive their certificate from Lord Hodge.
Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion

Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion

Range of Opinion is the focus of the 5th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast. We catch up with Colin Holburn, Chair of the EWI Membership Committee,...
A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert

A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert

Tim White is a chartered chemist who uses his expertise to assess chemical risk from exposure to water. He has been an Expert Witness for over 40...
Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees

Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees

Simon and Sean discuss expert fees and catch up with Dominic Woodhouse from Partners in Costs to talk about cost management and budgeting in civil...
A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert

A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert

Jerry Ponder uses his 40+ years of experience in fitted interiors to provide expert evidence on the design, product quality, installation and project...

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

EWI Annual Conference 2024: Closing address focuses on the evolving Expert Witness and the challenges this brings
Simon Berney-Edwards 770

EWI Annual Conference 2024: Closing address focuses on the evolving Expert Witness and the challenges this brings

bySimon Berney-Edwards

Our annual conference took place on 17th May. Following a rousing keynote speech by The Rt. Hon. Sir Keith John Lindblom, The Hon. Mrs. Justice Bacon delivered her closing address on how the role of the Expert Witness has evolved in modern litigation and the challenges this presents for experts, those instructing them, and judges alike.

 

In a fascinating address, Mrs Justice Bacon drew on the history of the Expert Witness — did you know the earliest recorded use of an expert was back in 1554? — to frame present-day challenges.

 

Drawing on her extensive experience as a barrister and judge, she identified four key areas that often present difficulties for experts and gave her recommendations on how to mitigate them.

 

Four main points of discussion:

  • How to define and limit the source material for an expert report
  • Cognitive bias
  • The relationship between the expert and the legal team
  • Giving evidence at trial

 

Source material

Mrs Justice Bacon discussed the approaches that can be taken to ensure that expert reports are produced concisely and efficiently, avoiding indigestible and irrelevant information.

 

“A real problem which faces many trial judges is the amount of material presented to the court,” she observed. “An important question for the courts when they are case managing trials with expert evidence is how to ensure that the expert reports are produced in a proportionate and efficient way.”

 

Cognitive bias

Acknowledging that all humans are susceptible to cognitive bias, Mrs Justice Bacon highlighted that expert witnesses come under a further type of pressure, known as allegiance bias, when they are instructed by one party in a case.

 

“How, then”, she asked, “to resolve the dilemma of the expert who is expected to be a paragon of objectivity but who is subject to unavoidable biases?”

 

The relationship between the expert and the legal team

In some fields, the production of the expert report requires a high level of involvement by the lawyers.  Mrs Justice Bacon explained: “The reality is that almost every expert will need considerable guidance from their legal team as to the structure and content of their report, so as to ensure that what they produce is relevant and helpful to the court and is written in terms that can be understood by the other side and ultimately the judge.”

 

But too much involvement from lawyers can present challenges of its own, including the risk of experts losing their objectivity. Mrs Justice Bacon suggested methods that experts can consider to clearly define where the lawyers’ roles begin and end.

 

How to give evidence in court

Have you heard the analogy about the hedgehog and the fox? “A hedgehog-like witness tends towards a single central thesis which is approached with unwavering commitment”, Mrs Justice Bacon explained.

 

“A fox-like witness tends towards self-doubt, questions their own view and considers alternative explanations. Of course, the real world is not binary like this, but a continuum. And real-world experts will fall somewhere along that continuum.”

 

But when it comes to giving your expert evidence in court, should experts be striving towards hedgehog or fox? Listen to Mrs Justice Bacon’s speech to find out.  

 

Recordings from the entire Annual Conference will be available from next week, but if you want to hear The Hon. Mrs. Justice Bacon’s full closing speech you can access this now.

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.