17 July Case Updates X and Y (Care Proceedings: Publication of Judgment: Criticism of Expert Witness), Re guidance, 16. Criticism and Complaints, ECHR, 06. Rules and Regulations, General Medical Council In her judgment on X and Y (Care Proceedings: Fact Finding: Death of a Child), the Judge was highly critical of the evidence and conduct during proceedings of one of the expert witnesses, a consultant neurosurgeon, Mr M. This judgment, which should be read alongside the earlier judgment, dealt with whether Mr M should be named within that published judgment.