Preliminary (pre-report) experts’ meetings Preliminary (pre-report) experts’ meetings

Preliminary (pre-report) experts’ meetings

Experts, in particular medical experts, are likely to be familiar with experts’ discussions that take place after the exchange of reports. This...
A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Medicolegal Expert Witness

Sue Lightman is a Professor of Ophthalmology and Consultant Ophthalmologist who has been undertaking medicolegal Expert Witness work for over 20...
Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd v Khan & Ors [2024] EWCA Civ 531 Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd v Khan & Ors [2024] EWCA Civ 531

Solicitors Regulation Authority Ltd v Khan & Ors [2024] EWCA Civ 531

This case is about whether the judge erred in finding that Ms Soophia Khan had capacity to defend proceedings for contempt of court. This is an...
Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner

Thomas Murray Joins EWI as a Corporate Partner

We are pleased to welcome a new Corporate Partner
Pfizer Inc v Uniqure Biopharma BV [2024] EWHC 2672 (Pat) Pfizer Inc v Uniqure Biopharma BV [2024] EWHC 2672 (Pat)

Pfizer Inc v Uniqure Biopharma BV [2024] EWHC 2672 (Pat)

The judge in this patent case found that the claimants’ gene therapy expert had developed, quite possibly guided by lawyers, the understanding...
Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture

Celebrating Success at the Sir Michael Davies Lecture

Successful Certification candidates receive their certificate from Lord Hodge.
Independence, bias and conflicts of interest Independence, bias and conflicts of interest

Independence, bias and conflicts of interest

Hon Mr Justice Trower provides invaluable guidance for Expert Witnesses at the 2024 the Sir Michael Davies lecture.
Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion

Podcast Episode 5: Range of Opinion

Range of Opinion is the focus of the 5th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast. We catch up with Colin Holburn, Chair of the EWI Membership Committee,...
A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert

A Day in the Life of a Water Quality Expert

Tim White is a chartered chemist who uses his expertise to assess chemical risk from exposure to water. He has been an Expert Witness for over 40...
Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees

Podcast Episode 4: Expert Fees

Simon and Sean discuss expert fees and catch up with Dominic Woodhouse from Partners in Costs to talk about cost management and budgeting in civil...
A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert

A Day in the Life of a Fitted Kitchen and Bathroom Expert

Jerry Ponder uses his 40+ years of experience in fitted interiors to provide expert evidence on the design, product quality, installation and project...
Podcast Episode 3: Single Joint Expert Podcast Episode 3: Single Joint Expert

Podcast Episode 3: Single Joint Expert

Simon and Sean discuss Single Joint Experts and catch up with two EWI members who act as Single Joint Experts to hear about their experiences, the...

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

The importance of getting your CV right and preparing for court
Simon Berney-Edwards 1773

The importance of getting your CV right and preparing for court

bySimon Berney-Edwards

The case of Watts v Watts [2023] EWHC 679 (Ch). involves the contest of a will and, specifically whether a will made in 2000 was a forgery.

 

Although the Master hearing the case was satisfied with the evidence and the witness of fact provided by the defence, the expert evidence was considered.

 

The judgment makes interesting reading. Not least because it highlights the importance of making sure the CV you include within your expert report really demonstrates why you have the suitable qualifications or experience to act as an Expert Witness in the case.

 

Getting your CV right

In the case, the claimant’s expert had set out his CV which seemed to demonstrate that his work was focussed on the analysis of paper and paper properties as opposed to handwriting analysis.

 

In the judgement, Master Clark highlights:

 

“There is nothing in this description or in Mr C’s CV that refers to or demonstrates expertise in handwriting analysis. Although in cross-examination, he said that his qualifications under the guidelines of the Scientific Working Group for Document Examiners (SWGDOC) included traditional handwriting analysis, there is nothing in his CV to show that he has ever carried out such an analysis.”

 

This highlights two possible issues:

  1. Either the Expert Witness was not the right type of Expert in the first place and was encouraged (or felt) that he could act outside of his usual area of expertise
  2. Or, usually working within the field of paper analysis but with the requisite knowledge or experience to undertake the examination of handwriting, he neglected to make sure his CV adequately reflected this

 

Either way, by this early point in the proceedings, the expert’s credibility had been called into question by the Judge which was obviously going to affect any weight that he put on his expert opinion.

 

And that, for me, is the key piece of learning from this case. As an expert, you need to make sure you do nothing which is going to call into question your credibility so that you find you are ‘on the back foot’ before you have even started.

 

Analysis and preparing for court

However, there was more criticism to come. Master Clark mentions that in cross -examination the expert “presented as confused, and was unable to explain the basis for his opinions.”

 

He mentions various deficiencies in this expert’s evidence, stating that he was:

  • Forced to accept that his analysis had be wrong and put this down to a typographical error.
  • Unable to provide an answer to key questions.
  • Confused on the points of the case within the report.
  • Did not fairly compare examples of the will.
  • Provided an inconsistent and ultimately not credible account of what he meant by tracing.
  • Drew conclusions in the absence of comparables, and therefore without analysis of similarities.
  • Could not explain the relevancy of some of his analysis.

 

In contrast, the defendant’s expert (an EWI member), provided a balanced report which:

  • made reference to 18 samples of the deceased and Defendant’s handwriting and signatures over a 65-year period.
  • identified natural variations.
  • undertook a forensic assessment of the deceased’s and Mrs Watts’ handwriting and signatures.

 

Master Clark concluded that he had no hesitation in accepting the evidence of the defendant’s expert.

 

So, what are the key learning points from this case?

  1. Ensure your CV adequately reflects why you are able to act as an expert in the case at hand.
  2. If you are not an expert, do not be strayed to act outside of your area of expertise.
  3. Ensure you read through your report carefully to check for typographical errors.
  4. Make sure your assessment of the evidence is balanced and be clear on the relevancy of the analysis.
  5. Prepare for court by ensuring you are clear on processes or technical jargon that you may be required to explain.

 

Want to feel more confident in your expert witness practice?

Our online conference on the 12th May includes a mock cross-examination which will demonstrate the issues that can be created when your report is not right in the first place and will provide you with an opportunity to discuss with other delegates how you might do things differently.

 

For more information and to book, please visit www.ewi.org.uk/AC22

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.